I am a self educated citizen when it comes to Charter Change. Your Captain is not involved with Saratoga Citizen or SUCCESS, (although I have friends in both groups). I feel it is up to the individual to do research on their own before making a decision. There are all kinds of posts on the various blogs, from insightful to the ridiculous. After doing some internet research I did find information on the Saratoga Citizen website informative, while honestly I couldn’t find out any information except for the donors of SUCCESS, on the internet. All the information I received about the group was from friends of mine who are members and have told me where they stand and why as told to them by Ms. Foy.
In researching the Commission form of government, which Saratoga has had for almost 100 years, I found that there are only 40 or so cities our size in the entire U.S. that use this form and about 76 total in the entire country. The Commission form, as almost everyone knows, was started because of a disaster in Texas and businessmen needed fast action to rebuild their losses. It still appears that the Commission form is promoted mostly by businessmen as evidenced by the list of donors of SUCCESS. There also seems to be a few ex politicians who suffered tough losses and really didn’t want to give up their power as backers of the group.
One phrase a friend said to me is ‘what is wrong with Saratoga ’? ‘Our City is the envy of cities across the country’ (this has also been said by Mayor Johnson). In response I said to her, there is absolutely nothing wrong with Saratoga Springs , we have a beautiful city and while I don’t believe we are the envy of the country, I find that many people like to live and visit our City. Saratoga has a great volunteer base, a great downtown, an active Chamber of Commerce, a very busy Convention Bureau, these things can’t be denied.
However, there is a double edged sword, while we have all the above, we also have a dysfunctional and costly government. The question one should ask themselves is, can our government run more efficiently and more streamlined? Do we need 5 payroll departments? Do we need to give City employees 15 minutes of work time to cash their checks on Friday? Do we need 8 unions, which our Mayor cannot negotiate expired contracts, should we turn a blind eye when the City fails to live up to the laws they set forth? Is there proper planning for 5 to 10 years out? Ten years is a stretch but there are some items that would benefit from a time period like this i.e. do we have a plan on the number of years and how many police cars needs to be rotated out for new ones? The same plan should be planned with fire vehicles, or do we wait 19 years until a fire truck catches fire while trying to put out a fire? By the way this last one made the national news.
It seems to me as I talk with people that young adults and those who moved here in the last 15 years or so favor a new form of government, while the ‘old guard’ of Saratoga favors the status quo, and if you ask them why, they have no answer other than to say ‘it’s always been this way’. One thing Saratoga Springs has is a very high percent of voter apathy. In the last primary, workers in 2 Districts reported a total of 6 and 7 people respectively, turning out to vote, (very sad).
Some people try to demonize Pat Kane, Brent Wilkes and anyone else in the Saratoga Citizen group. I feel the issue is the form of government and the information a group puts out, not the people behind it. If this were so, would that mean that if you disliked Remiga Foy, you would automatically say that SUCCESS is a bunch of crazies and be for charter change? Should Ms. Foy be demonized because she is adamant in keeping the status quo? I don’t think so.
I did my research first on the various forms of government and truth be told the Professional Manager, Council, Mayor form of government seems like the best one out there. Granted there is no form that is 100% perfect, but in today’s real world, running a government has become so difficult, that running a City without a qualified professional manager at the helm seems unreal. Would you hire a carpenter to run a $37 million dollar computer business? There are some who say that say they are for a strong Mayor, but it seems to me that you still are electing a pretty face who may be as dumb as a box of rocks.
Just one other thing, if you do your own research without having someone talk you into something you will feel more comfortable with your decision. A question that pops up frequently is the cost of a new government. The figures are out there, but think about this, if this new government form is voted in, it will be bound by the budget that is passed by the current Council, the very same Council that will be responsible for sifting through resume’s for a Professional Manager, one who will work under a Council elected by the citizens of Saratoga .
See how much information you can get if you take the time to do a little research?
I'm still trying to figure out what is going on with John Franck before thinking about charter change. What effect will it have if he is found to be doing inappropriate actions in that department. Not sure a city manager would be good or bad yet for that reason.
ReplyDeleteI understand your dilemma, however since we will have to wait for the Attorney General's report Charter change will still be on the ballot. You can still examine the facts on why or why not change the form to understand the process. As I said, no form of government is 100% perfect, however, I think with better oversight and true strong management they would have been contacted by the whistle blower, and this may have been handled differently. That said the AG's report will be the deciiding factor in this story.
ReplyDeleteI think you will be waiting a very long time for an AG report on this, as they are not investigating anything. What we have is an unstable and not particularly intelligent woman who did not understand what was going on, and she is being used by some of the commissioner's enemies. The sad part is that she thinks she is doing
ReplyDelete'"the right thing", but she is actually being used by a scumbag blogger and people close to the mayor (she is very close friends with the deputy mayor, for example, and the blogger who will not be named is very very tight with the mayor) to harm someone who thought she was his friend.
It really is sad and outrageous.
Now, as for charter change, the manager form is preferable, but the charter that will be on the ballot is so poorly written that I have a hard time supporting it.
I agree with everything but your last paragraph. A Charter should be an evolving document just as our Constitution is. I think the most important thing is for the change to happen, the document can be shaped by our elected Council and Mayor who we will elect to run the City and at least 2 or 3 can be removed every 2 years if one thinks they are not doing their jobs.
ReplyDeleteAgain, you are spot on with your take on the Commissioner of Accounts debacle. The woman you refer to has a trail of such behavior.
Thanks for the response.
Well I guess you have shown where Franck's damage control team hides out. Right here. Franck has been doing questionable things since he has been in office. Obviously you have not looked at what he has done. Shame on you. You probably are John Franck.
ReplyDeleteWell the fun is just beginning as always. The mayor has tried to take out his competition and has hit a single when he needed to hit a homerun. he now must turn and face his own music. I guesss Tuesday night will be packed with excitment. It will be the Franck vs Johson match. My money is on Franck. Johnson's Human Resourses Subcontractor is getting the boot and Johnson will have another black eye.
ReplyDeleteHe also will need to explain how paying 3X for his buddy Jelineck lost makes sense for public monies.
He is heading back into NYS Supreme court to block the charter referendum. He is refusing to supply Saratoga County Board of Elections the required legal paperwork to place the referendum on November's ballot.
I guess he likes keeping his legal buddies knee deep in tax payer money.
Keep on Spending
John Franck is othing but a grandstanding fool who has come to the end of his tenure. MisHandling the accounts department is the last straw. People are tired of getting screwed over and Franck is doing nothing but screwing these days.
ReplyDelete